PBA Real Talk: San Miguel was wrong for NOT BRINGING BACK CMC!

Let's just take a step back and look at the absolute insanity of what happened in Game 6 of the Commissioner's Cup Finals.

Justin Brownlee—the unquestioned apex predator of PBA imports, the guy who just dropped 54 points a few nights ago—puts up another absolute masterpiece. He drops 52 points. He looks completely unstoppable. In 99% of PBA games, if Brownlee goes for 52, you pack up the gym, hand Ginebra the trophy, and go home.

But wait. What happens? TNT doesn't flinch. Because they have Chris McCullough. And C-Mac decides to look at Brownlee's 52, raise him by one, and drop a career-high 53 points to carry the Tropang 5G and force a Game 7. It was an absolute heavyweight title fight.

And as I was watching McCullough drain four-pointers down the stretch and pull down 22 rebounds, I kept having the exact same thought: How in the world did the San Miguel Beermen let this guy slip through their fingers?

The "Wait, What?" Decision of the Year

If we are putting together the Mount Rushmore of terrible PBA front-office decisions for this decade, San Miguel passing on a Chris McCullough reunion is easily taking up the George Washington spot.

Let's look at the context here. McCullough didn't just stumble back into the Philippines. He was openly, actively campaigning to come back. He was completely honest and vocal about his desire to return to the PBA, specifically to play for San Miguel—the team he won a championship with! He even publicly lobbied to be naturalized for Gilas Pilipinas. He wanted to be here. He practically gift-wrapped himself for the SMB management.

And what did the Beermen brass do? They passed. They looked at a guy in his prime, a guy with a proven championship pedigree in their exact system, and said, "Nah, we're good."

Whoever made that final call in the San Miguel boardroom needs to be penalized. Seriously, take away their executive parking spot. Suspend their access to the corporate suite. Because right now, that decision looks like organizational malpractice.

Look at the Numbers, People!

I'm looking at his numbers for this tournament, and it just makes the SMB decision look even more baffling. McCullough is a walking cheat code. He is averaging 29.8 points, 13.2 rebounds, and 1.6 blocks per game, all while shooting an incredibly efficient 47% from the field.

He is doing everything. He’s protecting the rim, he’s stretching the floor, and when the offense bogs down, he just takes the ball and says, "Get out of my way."

San Miguel has always prided itself on having an embarrassment of riches. But when you have a chance to bring back a mercenary who actively wants to bleed for your franchise—and who possesses the exact skillset to go toe-to-toe with Justin Brownlee in a seven-game series—you do not let him walk into the locker room of your biggest corporate rival.

The Game 6 Legacy

What we saw in Game 6 was historic. According to the PBA stat gurus, it was the first time both finalists had 50-point players since 1989. Brownlee was spectacular, but McCullough was inevitable. He carried TNT on his back when they were missing key local stars, proving that he is one of the very few imports on this planet who can neutralize the Ginebra mystique.

San Miguel fans have to be watching this series through their fingers, feeling completely sick to their stomachs. They could have had him. They should have had him. Instead, they are sitting at home watching Chris McCullough write his name into the PBA history books wearing a TNT jersey.

Basketball GM

NBA

Search This Blog